「Inside-outed II」

Episode 10 truly elevated this series, making it anime of the season. I haven’t bawled so hard consuming fiction in such a long time – since Clannad actually, which also featured similar heart-wrenching loss of loved ones and an illusionary world that fell apart once the protagonist regains his memories.

Narihisago, desperate to spend more time with his deceased loved ones, convinces himself that this fake matrix is reality – allowing him to live with his wife and daughter for over a year. And I don’t blame him one bit. It was the least he deserved, considering they were cruelly torn away from him way before their time. Part of me was angry towards Hondomachi for bringing such a beautiful and heart-wrenching dream to an end. That said, she couldn’t have known any better. And Narihisago admits it might have been for the better. The matrix is just a dream at the end of the day. And John Walker is still at large in the real world, while Kiki Asukai needs to be saved.

The montage where he reminisces about the special times he had with his family really made you feel the depth of love he had towards them. That they meant everything to him. You could acutely sense how utterly destroyed he became when his daughter was brutally and unfairly murdered, with his wife committing suicide shortly afterwards. He lost every reason to live. Though he didn’t suffer a physical death, anyone could pinpoint this as the moment where Narihisago died. I don’t understand how people could fault him for immediately rushing out to gun down the Challenger. That’s just the pure hatred you can only get from losing your nearest and dearest in such an unspeakable way. It really fucking hurt to see it happen. Ah fuck, I don’t think there’s any word that exists to properly convey my thoughts or do these scenes justice. It’s just rough and impossible to describe. Don’t even get me started on the insert song.

Browsing online forums, it definitely looks like I’m not alone on this one. And it’s a testament to ID Invaded’s excellence – that it managed to elicit such a powerful and emotional reaction from its viewers, an accolade very few other works can claim to have achieved. With no other show even coming close to that mark this season, let alone recent years, ID Invaded has rightfully earned its spot as anime of the season by my current estimations – though that might always be subject to change depending on what kind of note it ends on.


John Walker’s been manipulating Narihisago this whole time. And it makes sense how it can give Narihisago such restraint. With The Challenger killed by his hands, his hatred has found a new pathway – because he’s come to realise John Walker definitely played a part in the death of his family. Perhaps he even orchestrated the entire thing to transform Narihisago into a serial killer that kills serial killers. That would be a dark development even if it was within the realm of expectations.

And we discover that due to the hole he drilled into his own head, Anaido can remember everything from diving into the ID Wells – which also applies to Hondomachi. We’re also told the reason why he drilled the hole, and how it’s connected to his quick deaths when diving into ID Wells. Turns out Fukuda used to have unbearable arithmomania – a condition where he cannot help but obsess with numbers. John Walker was the one who compelled him to drill a hole in his own head, which fixed the condition. But strangely enough, for whatever reason, Fukuda refused to drill a hole into Kiki Asukai’s head – affirming that Fukuda is not in the cahoots with John Walker. And returning to the ID Well returns Fukuda to a state where he suffers from arithmomania, being so unbearable he quickly seeks out the quickest way to die so that he can escape that personal hell of his. It doesn’t absolve him of the murders he committed. But that kind of backstory definitely makes me feel more sympathy for Fukuda.

The retained memory trait came in really handy for solving this case, because Hondomachi solves the mystery through recalling her time within the inception ID Well. John Walker is indeed the section chief – I repeat, it wasn’t a red herring. And I’m glad that they went with an established character, as opposed to pulling a new big bad out of the hat. However, it’s difficult to put a finger on his motive. Just why would he do such fucked up things? My first thought is that he must be a sadist who relishes in suffering. My second thought is that with supernatural abilities existing within this fictional setting, perhaps John Walker has an unrevealed power of his own that can bestow him a god-like status. Kiki said that she felt the world was in imminent danger – suggesting to me that the director has some grand plans in mind.

If John Walker can invade dreams and control them, what if Kiki Asukai could be made to project her dreams upon the global populace? If he possesses these hypothetical powers – which wouldn’t be farfetched looking back on what he’s been able to do so far in this series, he could theoretically control every person on the planet and become the god of a new reality. Of course, that’s one heck of a crazy fan theory to go with. But that’s my hunch for now, and I’d like to see how everything will play out – since we’re so close to the end.

Apologies for the delays. Started a new job, had to move out of home into a new place, etc. Process took a while, but the busiest parts are done and I should have time to release these posts more punctually. Anyway, that’s about everything I wanted to discuss. As always, thanks for reading this post and catch you all next week!


  1. Pingback: ID Invaded – 10, 11 - World's entertainment latest updates

  2. These last episodes perfectly encapsulate my love/hate relationship with this show. On the one hand, you have the stuff within the well, which, while cliche, were still moving and interesting. (That kid of stuff always gets me, and I have to admit I teared up when the flashes of his family before they died were on screen)

    On the other side, you have the plot, ie that the bearded man who looks just like John Walker, is in fact, John Walker. I mean, it was kind of obvious from the very beginning with how they kept talking about how little was known about the Mizuhanome, it all being so secretive, and the Chief cut them off every single time they tried to learn anything about it.

    From the very moment they established Asukai Kiki as able to attract murderers and bring other people into her dreams, the fact that she was the Mizuhanome and was kidnapped for that purpose really should have been obvious to anyone. The only reason why these secrets weren’t obvious much sooner, was because her character came completely out of nowhere with zero setup, almost as if they knew they couldn’t set up her character early on for fear it would be too obvious what was going on. It still was, at least not as much.

    All in all, this series is pretty poorly written story wise, and cliche as all hell, but it’s had some really interesting ideas in its background, which have kept me watching. I feel like this series is kind of dissapointing to me, simply because I can see how, with a better, and more well told narrative, it could of been something really great.

    It was still a fun watch though.

    1. I’d disagree. Technically Asukai Kiki was always there right at the start just no one realized it until later. The Chief being the bad guy while not a shocking reveal sometimes it makes much more sense when it is just that.

      I actually like the show more because of its crazy characters and their dialog the minority report plot is just the background in which they inhabit.

      1. Please name a single time her character was named or even referenced before the episode when the head guy was arrested.

        If I missed it, I apologize. Otherwise, this is excuses for bad writing.

        1. In the credits of the episode 03 she was credited as the voice of Kaeru so there a pretty huge foreshadowing right there. Even without that dead giveaway you can use inference to deduce the thing the system produces without fail is pretty central to what the system is. The character was referenced every time they entered the well it literally is central to each dive. Sure it is only crystal clear after they reveal her but it is anything but bad writing. I don’t think it is upto the show to spell out every little detail right from the start as that would be bad writing. They alluded to things and showed it heavily with a little easter egg in the credits.

  3. That musical montage in episode 10 really was something. How often do you see that in an anime?

    The overall story is kind of weak, but the characters are what really make this show good. I’m not sure it would be considered anime of the season, That would probably go to Eizouken or Somali. I will admit that this show is very unique.

    1. I dunno Eizouken’s intial shine kinda wore off on me as time went on. Somali is good but ID has top notch execution on its premise. I think the story is really good as the characters are fun to watch and the plot about dreams within dreams is pretty easy to follow.

  4. Just binged watched all the episodes up to now, the chief was easily the top suspect for being John Walker like right at the beginning when I first saw him lol. I guess the John Walker’s appearance was too much of a giveaway as it suits the chief too well.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *