Random Curiosity

Ballroom e Youkoso – 09 »« Ballroom e Youkoso – 07

Ballroom e Youkoso – 08

「現実」 (Genjitsu)

There are definitely times when watching Ballroom e Youkoso that my abject lack of knowledge about ballroom dancing generally – and competitive specifically – frustrates me. I’m sure the series’ depiction isn’t photo-realistic or anything (nor would I expect it to be), but it clearly makes an effort to dig into the details and to get them right. More so than, say, volleyball or karuta, I feel as if not getting the subtleties really hampers my appreciation of the challenges facing the cast (especially Tatara). Whether that’s a function of the sports in question or the manner in which they’re portrayed, I couldn’t say.

Take, for example, the issue of leading and following. I know that ballroom dance couples have a partner who leads – I’m not a complete ignoramus – but what does that mean, exactly? It’s not something that reading the Wikipedias of the world can really answer, either – and it’s a crucial point. One of the criticisms I’ve seen of Ballroom e Youkoso is that the female characters are too passive (especially Shizuku). But traditionally, it is the male partner who leads and the female who follows – on the dance floor, at least. To what extent does she impart her own influence on the end product a dance couple produces, in competition or otherwise?

This is a critical matter for this arc, obviously. You have the beginner Tatara trying to partner with the experienced but timid Mako-chan, whose previous partner (her brother) railed against her for not offering any input into their routines. And the nature of the wager that underpins this competition is a factor, too, because it’s all about Mako proving she’s good enough to stay with Gaju – by dancing with someone else. Tatara seems to take the approach of trying to take everything onto his own shoulders, which is understandable and may reflect his own lack of understanding of the fine details of a dance partnership. But clearly, though the chibi couple does keep scraping by round by round (Tatara’s earnest appreciation of dance is winning over Tenpei-san for sure), it’s not really working.

There’s another issue, too, which is that Tatara is dancing “too big”. This I sort of get – he’s a novice unused to the rigors of a full tournament (Sengoku says he normally loses 2 kilos in one, and unlike Tatara he can spare them), and his learning style is imitation so he’s trying to parrot the routines he’s seen Sengoku and Hyodo do. Tatara is inexperienced, yes, but immature physically as well – he needs a scaled-down program for his scaled-down body. But he lacks the experience to know that, and because his coach is clearly incompetent at coaching, he’s not getting any direction either. If indeed Tatara is really Sengolu’s first student as Marisa says, I suppose that would be his excuse for being such a failure as a mentor, but given all the strikes against him I think it’s remarkable that Tatara is doing as well as he is.

Hyodo-kun does, at least, try and offer Tatara some guidance – though it confuses him as much as guides him. That Tatara can’t beat Gaju at this stage is the easy part to understand – that’s obvious. But Hyodo’s advice to beat Shizuku is where things get difficult. What Hyodo seems to be saying is that Tatara-kun needs to concentrate on making Mako better – to be her “frame”, as he puts it. If Tatara was guilty of “dancing by himself” as Kiyoharu says, then he’s really only doing what Gaju-kun did when he danced with Mako. And since we know that really didn’t work – and indeed, led us to the straits we’re currently in – it only makes sense for Tatara to try and do more by doing less.

Given that this is a shounen – and not just a shounen, but an especially “shounen” one – the focus on the battle of wills between the boys is expected. But I too am at the point where I want to see the girls assert themselves more (and less focus on the lamer fanservice gags from the manga). I enjoyed seeing a Shizuku-Tatara moment because they’ve been few and far-between lately, but even here Shizuku stresses how she’s certain that the “special” Kiyoharu-kun will leave her behind. Leading and following may be part of ballroom dance, but there’s no reason why Shizuku and Mako shouldn’t be protective of their own destiny as far as who they partner with – it should be their choice and no one else’s. But so far – especially with Shizuku – we’ve had precious little indication of their feelings on that question. Tatara, at least, seems like a boy who’s in command of his own ego enough to embrace that, and I hope we start to see a lot more of it in the next few episodes.



August 26, 2017 at 7:44 pm
  • August 26, 2017 at 9:58 pmstarss

    What???? Did this ep arrive early!?

  • August 27, 2017 at 1:04 amWorldwidedepp

    If Mako chan is really more experienced, then she “let herself be lead” from Tatara, but she lead in truth. She let is seems like Tatara is still leader, but she push him into the right direction. But Tatara need to know it, that her partner suddenly put more force into her movements

    But, i am also not experienced in how you can see, who is leading in a Dance. Perhaps the Male is the one where they “walk”, always ahead and the Female follow.. But what is the Female force him going ahead?. She has the known length where the leader and she should be, and what comes next.. as if some “center” of AKB48 suddenly must jump in for some Background dancer, but still yells the commands silently. But the Group must know the performance

    • August 27, 2017 at 1:14 amWorldwidedepp

      Example: The Male leads here, because he is in the Center of this Pirouette/Whirl figure, the female “follow” from the outside.. You can not imagine if the female is the Center and the Male make this “bend your backbone and let you get swirl around”…

      i think this is the base of leading and be lead

    • August 27, 2017 at 1:22 pmAsoch

      It goes beyond that. I am not an expert ballroom dancer. But I have been a Latin dancer my whole life. The truth is that the female is as good as her partner is… If your partner sucks you can’t fix it but if your partner is good even is you’re average your dancing is going to be good… What may change is how complicated the routine becomes and how fluent also. The leading is not pushing…. If there are pushes then the judges will see them and take points out. What there is subtle movements. The lead goes in the arms mostly… Guys are trained on how to transmit the direction and the women are train on recognizing it. But it really is very subtle… Like a little nuggle in your right hand.

      Whereas an experience woman can lead… Guys are judge on their leading (I have friends who compete) if Mako was leading, they would get points out. They are also judge in their foot work. So if tatara didn’t know where the feet are going that would take points out. I actually loved that they mentioned that tatara’s feet were getting flat. Because that’s one of the samples of what your foot work is judge on.

      What kioharu’s comment about the frame probably meant… Is that Tatara is too focus on imitating other people’s style, but that doesn’t match his partners style. So instead of working in team, Mako has to follow him to try to match whatever he is putting out there.

  • August 27, 2017 at 1:30 amChris hall

    • August 27, 2017 at 1:46 amWorldwidedepp

      ..and she is a mother…

  • August 27, 2017 at 5:33 amGlutton


    I don’t think Hyodo made things any more complicated than Sengoku unnecessarily did.

  • August 31, 2017 at 7:22 pmlunascha

    Oh many Hyodo is so cool lol