Random Curiosity

« Ballroom e Youkoso – 23

Ballroom e Youkoso – 24 (END)

「ボールルームへようこそ」 (Ballroom e Youkoso)
“Welcome to the Ballroom”

Think back on this for a second: how many anime end with their finest episode? I would have to imagine it’s a pretty small number, because there aren’t a hell of a lot of examples popping into my head. But it’s awfully nice when it does happen, and for my money it absolutely did with Ballroom e Youkoso. I could hardly have imagined a more satisfying way to bring this series to a conclusion (apart from one niggle which is down to personal taste, which I’ll discuss in a bit). And that’s all the more remarkable when you consider that the anime actually moved ahead of the manga with this final episode.

Series review posts are always a bit of a puzzle to write, because you have to balance your views of the finale with your views on the series as a whole. In the case of Welcome to the Ballroom I find the two to be rather conflated, and I find myself wanting to talk about the overall picture first – but I don’t think that’s right. And it’s not as though there wasn’t plenty to talk about with this episode, which worked both as a deft conclusion to the linear plot and as a kind of “closing argument” for why Ballroom matters as a story.

One thing that’s fair to say in my case is that the rivalry between Tatara-kun and Kugimiya-san greatly improved the series with its development – even with its relative late entry into the narrative, their relationship may just have been the most interesting one in the show. They’re such fascinating opposites, these two, that it’s hard not to be fascinated watching them interact both on the dance floor and off. The tall, elegant man and the mere slip of a boy – the traditionalist and the revolutionary, the glower and the goofy smile. As people and as dancers, they represent two very different poles.

The most interesting way these two differ, though, is in their basic personality – and as such, their reason for being on the dance floor. This was something the final episode did brilliantly as part of that closing argument – show us why Tatara dances. I believe, on some level, everyone wants – and deserves – to be able to shout “Look at me!” to the world. Even shy people (and I believe Tatara is a shy person) long to be the center of attention sometimes, especially for something they’re good at. This, for me, is the visceral draw of competitive dance – it’s a sport, performance art and an explosion of personal expression all rolled into one. For Tatara, it’s what allowed him to finally become a full person – something everyone will discover in adolescence if they’re very lucky.

Kugimiya, by contrast, is always asking himself the question “Why do I dance?” He talks of having Hell on his shoulders, of how he’s come to hate dance and truly viewed his life-threatening injuries as a lucky break, a chance to escape. This is a complicated, fascinating man, and his relationship with Idogawa-san likewise fascinating. There’s the sense (and this is a general frustration I have with Ballroom) that we’ve barely scratched the surface with this character. And truth be told, that’s even more true in the manga – which is why it’s so frustrating (there’s that word again) that Kugimiya’s cousins only appeared in the ED sequence after being totally cut from the final arc for no obvious reason (apart from wasting more screen time on Akira). They humanized his character in a very important way, and it’s a shame the anime staff decided to play down Kugimiya’s personal story somewhat.

Truth be told, I would have been happy to see either the Kugimiya-Idogawa or Tata-Natsu pairs win – though that niggle for me is that, on balance, I thought both contextually and narratively it really should have been Kugimiya. Either way, though, it was in contrasting these two pairs that Ballroom e Youkoso was able to most successfully deconstruct the nature of competitive dance for the audience. Although one of the pressmen tormenting Gaju-kun noted the similarity to figure skating (which I acknowledge) I think there’s an important difference – even after the phasing out of the 6.0 system, the ISU system in skating does separate out Total Element Score and Program Components Score (in the old days, technical merit and artistic impression). In dance it’s just one judge, one vote – it does indeed all come down to taste. And I truly believe that worked to the kids’ advantage here.

For me, Tatara had already won before the judges’ verdict was ever read, because he’d discovered both his own reason to dance and his way forward with Chinatsu. Again, it’s frustrating because it feels as if we’ve just scratched the surface with his character too – how did his apparent abandonment by his mother drive his need to stand out and be acknowledged? Why is he so reluctant to involve his father in this part of his life, when by all appearances they seem to be quite close? What is clear is that dance allows Tatara to do what he always wished for himself – to be a bigger presence in the world. Sengoku’s obsessive attention to posture way back in the beginning was clearly very important in a symbolic sense.

I have sensed some frustration with the anime version of Welcome to the Ballroom from manga readers (I’ve really only read bits and pieces of it, and apart from the first few chapters read it after them after the corresponding events in the anime) – part of it with the relative lack of extended animated dance sequences. On the whole, though, the anime seems to have been quite well-received – though not by the disc-buying audience, sadly. And I think it mostly succeeded with what it set out to do – tell one boy’s story of how dance changed his life, and what it is about these strange and puzzling sport that some people find so compelling.

For me too Ballroom e Youkoso was largely a success – though as is so often the case with adaptations of ongoing manga, there’s a sense that the anime is ending just when the real story is getting started. With the mangaka Takeuchi-sensei’s continuing health problems it’s going to be some while before the story progresses much even in the manga, and even if we were to get another season (which seems very unlikely) it would be a long ways down the road. That’s the ongoing frustration of the anime fan, but I have no regrets – I’m glad I spent time getting to know these characters and fascinating sport they devote their lives to.



ED3 Sequence

ED3: 「」 () by ()
Watch the 3rd ED!: Streaming ▼

December 18, 2017 at 7:32 pm
  • December 18, 2017 at 9:50 pmChris hall

  • December 19, 2017 at 11:15 amWorldwidedepp

    I liked it a lot, but it began with the appearing of Chinatsu

    • December 20, 2017 at 12:58 pmWorldwidedepp

      because with her introduction the ambition has leveled up and got strong enough to carry the anime..

  • December 19, 2017 at 6:38 pmstarss

    Damn. Only 2 comments in the first 24 hours of this posting… for the finale! Man has this show gone down.

  • December 19, 2017 at 8:23 pmARQ

    Speaking from the perspective of a huge fan of the manga who was really looking forward to the anime, I feel like this series really would have benefitted from yuri on ice’s level of animation quality for the dances. I don’t mean the body twisting angles which some people were put off by, but just the dance sequences themselves. There were too many closeups and stills which really doesn’t capture the motion of the dances and as the central part of this series, it really doesn’t live up to the dynamic artstyle from the manga.

    That said, I still enjoyed the adaptation and appreciated the ending they made. Hopefully the author will recover enough to continue writing and we’ll have a continuation some day in the future.

    • December 20, 2017 at 11:45 amGuardian Enzo

      I certainly don’t disagree that there was a very different approach taken by Yuri on Ice. But I think we romanticize a bit too much in hindsight, because there were some serious animation craters in that show when time and/or money was obviously short. There were highs for sure, but lows as well.

    • December 20, 2017 at 1:27 pmLitho

      All budget spent on the necks, I guess.

  • December 22, 2017 at 10:47 pmRathje

    Am I the only one who didn’t think Tatara-Chinatsu should have won 1st place? I was totally ready for them to take 2nd place and Kugimiya to win it.

    Sure Tatara and Chinatsu had some breakthroughs in their dance partnership and all. But that didn’t really feel like it was enough to win against Kugimiya’s much more consistently solid performance throughout the competition. The judges went from only one judge really liking the Tatara pair and the other judges giving him weird looks, to all the judges suddenly changing their mind and awarding the whole competition to them. It didn’t make sense.

    It made sense for Tatara’s big breakthrough and comeback to launch him into 2nd, but not 1st place.

    And it would have still been a success for the couple, since Marissa Sensei expressly revised her requirement for them to win to “it’s OK to take 2nd place since Kugimiya’s competing too.”

    It makes me wonder if the animation studio decided to make the MC couple win so that they could wrap up an anime that probably won’t be getting a third season. The mangaka has been sick and struggling to keep up with the needed publishing schedule. The anime has actually gone beyond what the mangaka has even released. Maybe the studio just wasn’t convinced that a season three was likely and decided to force a plot resolution by having the MC couple win.

    It’s a little too tidy. I wouldn’t be surprised at all if the mangaka didn’t mean for them to win it. I wonder what the competition result will be in the manga.

    • December 24, 2017 at 10:50 amRathje

      I’ll answer my question. No – I’m not the only one. Apparently the review author thought so too, and I just needed to do a better job of reading since the review made several of the same points I did.

      • December 24, 2017 at 11:39 amguardian enzo

        All good, LOL. We’re definitely in agreement on that one.

Leave a Reply

Please DO NOT ask or give links to raws, subs, or PVs. Instead, please check the Community section on the sidebar for useful links.
Gravatars are supported, so please sign up for a free account if you would like your own globally recognized avatar.

HTML tags are enabled for comments: <a href="" title=""> <b> <blockquote> <em> <i> <s> <spoiler> <strike> <strong>
** Please use <spoiler></spoiler> around any major spoilers. **