Random Curiosity

Girlish Number – 12 (END) »« ViVid Strike – It’s the Characters, Stupid

WWW.Working!! – Love and Peace and Lessons

Chocolate is a helluva drug.

It’s easy to see how the source material of WWW.Working!! led to the main WORKING!! series that was so popular. Every mistake the 2002+ Web-ban manga made was corrected for the 2004 serialization. This is an adaptation of that web manga, though, so the mistakes all remain.

I’m going to talk about WWW.Working’s mistakes a lot this post, but it’s important to bear this in mind: I didn’t hate this show. I enjoyed it much of the time, and I kept up with it throughout the season, as opposed to most other series which I either lapsed on or had to marathon at the end. (Through no fault of their own; I have too many jobs.) The biggest benefit working for WWW.Working!! is that Takatsu Karino-sensei’s comedic beats are well in evidence. This series was frequently funny, and charming as well. The reason I’ll be mostly discussing mistakes is that they’re more interesting, and because comparing this Wagnaria to Popura’s Wagnaria shows how much a strong foundation matters to telling a great story.

Most of the mistakes have to do with characters. The biggest is that most of the characters’ personalities, and more importantly their eccentricities, aren’t, frankly, all that good. Take Muranushi—she’s an emotionless girl with supernatural sight she refuses to accept. The latter has potential, but not when she refuses to react, and the former overlaps with Higashida’s own emotionless aspect—especially since both frequently hide annoyance and/or anger. Adachi is the worst among them all—I seriously forgot what his eccentricity was for half the season. He saw Muranushi smile, and now he’s all meek? Boring.

Compare this to Shindou and Kamakura, who are very well characterized. The son of the debtor and the daughter of the creditor. The poor guy with bad luck, and the rich girl with a sadistic streak. They even share a strong conflict point of money. You might not like this pair—I’ll get to a problem with them shortly—but they’re well done. Compare them to Kouno or the manager, who are just sort of . . . there, and you can see the asymmetry in the cast.

This foundational problem leads to nearly every other mistake, including this next one, which is really two sides of the same coin. First, because many of the characters weren’t well-established, they were underutilized, because how much can you do with a character like Saiki who doesn’t speak very good Japanese? (About as much as Maya from the main series, which is probably why she hardly ever showed up.) This then made it feel like, second, that there were too many characters, even though WWW.Working had the same number of employees as Popura’s Wagnaria (ten), and a similar number of supporting cast. While fewer characters certainly works (see: Takatsu-sensei’s Servant x Service), WORKING!! proved that this level works fine, as long as they’re stronger characters. They weren’t here, so it felt like a lot of them were wasting our time. Kouno could have been deleted without losing anything, and while I would have missed Kisaki, she and the manager didn’t add much either.

I have a feeling that the way these characters just weren’t working led to the other major problem, which is that events didn’t flow naturally from the characters’ actions. Once again, Kamakura and Shindou were the exception, because their actions did flow from their actions, and their conflict with each other. But why did Saitou pivot from having some kind of past with Muranushi to completely being an accessory to Kamakura and Shindou’s story? That never made sense to me. I also don’t understand why Higashida decided to re-ask out Miyakoshi, even though I’m kind of glad he did, because I like Miyakoshi a lot (though maybe she deserves better). And no, I’m not saying it needs to make logical sense; many would argue that Souta choosing Mahiru over the far-superior Popura was the height of illogic. It made sense in context though. Higashida never showed more than mild annoyance with Miyakoshi, until he suddenly didn’t. It didn’t track.

The last mistake is something of a balance issue: the guys are all too clearly the victims in their respective relationships. This isn’t an issue in and of itself, but when all three guys (Higashida, Adachi, and Shindou) are all on the receiving end of a fist, knife, or sword (Miyakoshi, Muranushi, Kamakura), it start feeling like it’s the girls’ fault. This wasn’t an issue with WORKING!!, where only Souta was any kind of victim—Yachiyo would never do anything to intentionally hurt Satou, and Yamada wanted to be doted on by Souma, not imperil him—but I think a better example is Gekkan Shoujo Nozaki-kun. In that series, it could have easily been oblivious Nozaki’s fault when they didn’t get together, but it didn’t feel like that since Sakura kept chickening out. That made it both of their faults, and moved it from an adversarial dynamic to a pair of dysfunctional people continually missing their chance due to their own goofy personalities. WWW.Working has neither balance—it’s also fine if the guy is the victim in one relationship (Wakamatsu & Seo), provided the girl is in another (Hori & Kashima)—nor symmetry, which made the gender dynamic noticeable. Preferably, it wouldn’t matter, because it would all come down to those specific, unique characters, as it did in WORKING!! and Servant x Service.

There were other issues, such as the shorter run-time giving the characters less time to breathe (which is an argument for a smaller cast, since Servant x Service only had one-cour and it worked fine), Miyakoshi’s toxic cooking being one of the weakest character conflicts I can imagine, and the supernatural elements not always working (Muranushi, Yanagiba), though Saint Valentine was probably my favorite part of the whole series. I also liked that WWW.Working wasn’t afraid to chew through the seasons in order to advance the narrative with what time it had, giving us an actual resolution instead of stretching for a second season it was never going to get. I also really liked Muranushi and Adachi’s relationship by the end, even if I still don’t understand them.

In the end, WWW.Working was more interesting for me to analyze that it was good. It was fine, but if it weren’t for WORKING this would have never been made into an anime, whereas Servant x Service was strong enough to deserve one on its own. If this had been written after WORKING, I would be beside myself with worry that Takatsu-sensei had lost her touch, but as the source material predates her other, better work, I’m much more sanguine. After all, I’ve seen how much my own writing has improved from my old work to the new, and I’ve been publishing for fewer years than Takatsu-sensei has. Hopefully the next anime we’ll get from her will be of her newer work. Or more Servant x Service. That would be fine with me too.

My SECOND novel, Freelance Heroics, is available now! (Now in print!) (Also available: Firesign #1 Wage Slave Rebellion.) Sign up for my email list for exclusive content. At stephenwgee.com, the last four posts: Conflicted feelings on the Electoral College; Voting Reform: Single Transferable Vote; They didn’t feel heard. I don’t feel heard. This is a problem; and What the hell do we do now?

December 25, 2016 at 10:04 am
  • December 25, 2016 at 10:39 pmZen

    While all of your criticisms are certainly legitimate- with WORKING and Servant x Service being the more narrative-mechanically solid series, I actually personally enjoyed WWW/WORKING significantly more than WORKING or even Servant x Service.

    I hate to say it, but Takatsu-sensei is a one-trick pony. WWW/WORKING, WORKING and Servant x Service are all essentially the same on a fundamental level. Takatsu generates comedic scenarios as a (dys)function of the interactions occurring between a stable of oddball characters, each with their own outlandish personality quirks, where the quirk itself is an emblematic manifestation of each character’s central internal personal conflict.

    Therefore, resolution of the characters’ personal conflicts also necessarily results in the disappearance or blunting of their quirks, which are themselves manifestations of that conflict. But the quirks are also the predominant source of comedic synergy; given the narrative construction of Takatsu’s works, continuous comedy is not easily sustainable without them.

    In WORKING and Servant x Service, both long running series, by the end of the first season (for both) and for all of the second season (for WORKING), both shows bored me. It’s because of the way Takatsu’s formula works, she just continuously plays these character quirks against each other ad nauseum to create comedy. Eventually it just becomes a cyclically repetitious routine of rehashed scenarios playing the same quirks against each other over and over again.

    It would be one thing if that was this formula’s only major flaw, but it’s not. Remember how the the personality quirks of Takatsu’s characters are always tied into some deep, internal personal conflict? Well, it creates an extremely inorganic, immersion breaking feel to the characters when they keep on acting out based on the same internal personal conflict for 30+ episodes on end (in the case of WORKING) with little to no development in relation to these internal personal conflicts (let alone resolution). That’s just not how real people are. They learn, they try to improve and achieve some measure of incremental improvement, they try to improve but fail miserably leaving themselves worse off than before, they deceive themselves into believing they are improving, etc.- real people are constantly evolving in the face of deep-seated emotional challenges- whereas a Takatsu character is robotically stagnant in this respect.

    And this stagnation remains, until it is time for the series to end- wherein we are presented with rapid, and again highly inorganic, resolution. Takatsu’s formula necessitates deferring resolution of the quirks/internal conflicts to the very end- because the moment these are resolved, continuous comedy becomes unsustainable in the long run.

    WWW/WORKING didn’t have these problems, where WORKING and Servant x Service did, mainly because it’s short. As WWW/WORKING was only meant to last one season, all quirks/internal conflicts were expanded upon and resolved within the span of that season. They weren’t allowed to overstay their welcome. By the time they started to get stale and/or cause the characters to seem inorganic due to repetitive, unevolving, robotic internal conflicts, the show was ending and resolution had begun; the dynamics changed.

    Basically, due to being short, WWW/WORKING never enters the “limbo” phase where the characters’ quirks/internal conflicts are artificially preserved for the sake of long-term, sustainable comedy, which results in repetitious scenarios and inorganic characterization. And so it did a far better job keeping me engaged, compared to WORKING and Servant x Service- although it is, on a fundamental level, no doubt the weakest of the three…

    • December 25, 2016 at 10:52 pmZen

      tl;dr: Certain critical flaws present in WORKING and Servant x Service weren’t present in WWW/WORKING; therefore WWW/WORKING did a better job of keeping me engaged and interested, although it is undoubtedly the weakest work of the three overall.

    • December 26, 2016 at 12:20 ambalbonits

      I’ll only comment on the part of the “one-trick pony”, since I do agree on many of both Stilts and your points:

      It might only be one trick, but it’s a damn good one.

    • December 26, 2016 at 5:03 pminfo600

      I can see why you didn’t see the limbo phase – WWW/WORKING kept jumping seasons to the point almost 3 years has past since the start of the series.

  • December 26, 2016 at 4:05 pmrandom viewer

    I read this and had to really rethink or refresh my memory of who was referred or compared to. I just got the point of it being a good enough series to air as an anime and that it was still enjoyable to watch. Probably would be even more confusing for those who didn’t watch the other mentioned anime series. Yet I’m sure there’s a deeper insight for those who know.

Leave a Reply

Please DO NOT ask or give links to raws, subs, or PVs. Instead, please check the Community section on the sidebar for useful links.
Gravatars are supported, so please sign up for a free account if you would like your own globally recognized avatar.

HTML tags are enabled for comments: <a href="" title=""> <b> <blockquote> <em> <i> <s> <spoiler> <strike> <strong>
** Please use <spoiler></spoiler> around any major spoilers. **